South Africa: New tax legislation and exchange control case

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

South Africa: New tax legislation and exchange control case

dachs.jpg

Peter Dachs

South Africa's new double tax agreement (DTA) with Mauritius was published in the Government Gazette of June 17 2015. In terms of article 28 of the new DTA, the provisions thereof shall only be effective in both countries from January 1 2016. The main changes introduced by the new DTA relate to dual residence for persons other than individuals, withholding taxes (dividends, interest and royalties) and capital gains.

Article 4 of the new DTA provides that if a person other than an individual is a resident of both South Africa and Mauritius, then the competent authorities of both contracting states shall by mutual agreement endeavour to settle the question of residency. In this regard, South Africa and Mauritius entered into a memorandum of understanding (MoU) on May 22 2015, which entered into force from May 28 2015, in terms of which both countries agreed the factors that shall be considered by the relevant competent authorities upon making such a determination.

A recent case heard by the Constitutional Court dealt with the constitutional validity of an exit charge levied by the South African Reserve Bank on the transfer of funds offshore from an emigrant's blocked account.

In 2014 the Supreme Court of Appeal found in favour of the appellant, Mark Shuttleworth, that the imposition of the 10% exit charge was invalid since the charge constituted a tax and should have been passed by Parliament as a money Bill in terms of section 77 of the Constitution. The South African Reserve Bank then took the matter on appeal to the Constitutional Court.

The Constitutional Court overturned the decision of the Supreme Court of Appeal. A majority of the Court found that the charge was not a revenue-raising mechanism which was required to be passed as a money Bill, but rather a regulatory charge. In coming to this decision the majority recognised that there is not always a clear distinction between a revenue-raising mechanism and a regulatory charge. A regulatory charge always generates revenue and a tax always has some regulatory effect. It is necessary, the majority found, to look at the dominant purpose of the charge.

Peter Dachs (pdachs@ensafrica.com)

ENSafrica – Taxand Africa

Tel: +27 21 410 2500

Website: www.ensafrica.com

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

The EU is preparing countermeasures to protect its interests, Ursula von der Leyen said; in other news, the NRA is suing the state of Colorado over a 6.5% tax on the sale of firearms
The ruling is ‘well-structured’ in its references to the OECD TP guidelines, one expert says, while another argues it overlooks key technical issues
India also brokered its first-ever multilateral APA last year, the Central Board of Taxes announced
A global tax framework may not materialise anytime soon, but a common set of principles is becoming increasingly necessary, Rudolf Winkenius also tells ITR
Kingsley Napley’s claimants are arguing that taxing the provision of education breaches the European Convention on Human Rights
While pillar two can progress without the US, it won’t reach the same heights without American involvement, argues Renáta Bláhová, founding partner of BMB Partners Taxand
There are unanswered questions as to how foreign investors could reclaim money via tax credits, advisers suggested
Amid an ever-changing tax environment, India’s advisory market is bustling with competition ahead of the 2025 World Tax rankings and ITR Awards
The deal comes after PwC had accused Paul McNab of using confidential information; in other news, McDermott hired a new London tax head from a US rival
Looking at transfer pricing simplification is “obviously helpful”, but it should be done in line with current standards, a senior government figure reportedly said
Gift this article