Canada: CRA GAAR committee documents compelled – Superior Plus Corp v the Queen

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Canada: CRA GAAR committee documents compelled – Superior Plus Corp v the Queen

kroft.jpg

richardson.jpg

Ed Kroft, QC


Casey Richardson-Scott

The Tax Court of Canada recently considered a taxpayer's entitlement to access records and information during the examination for discovery process regarding the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) decision to apply the general anti-avoidance rule (GAAR). In Superior Plus Corp v the Queen 2015 TCC 132, the taxpayer had appealed an assessment based, in part, on the decision of the CRA to apply the GAAR to a conversion of an income trust to a Canadian corporation. The taxpayer brought a motion to compel the CRA to answer questions that were refused during examination for discovery, to produce un-redacted copies of certain documents, and to produce documents for which production was refused outright, all pertaining to the CRA's decision to apply GAAR in the circumstances and to the underlying policies in the Income Tax Act (Canada) (ITA) that the CRA determined had been abused. The CRA had principally refused to answer the questions and produce the documents at issue on the basis of relevance.

In its decision, the Tax Court of Canada emphasised that the relevance threshold at the discovery stage is low. The court ultimately ordered that a majority of the refused questions be answered, and that a majority of the refused documents be produced in un-redacted form. Specifically, the court ordered that questions regarding the following be answered:

  • Facts, information or knowledge contributing to the Attorney General's position to be taken at trial;

  • Facts, information or knowledge regarding the Department of Finance's considerations as to whether to make a subsequent amendment to the ITA retroactive; and

  • The Attorney General's understanding of the policy regarding loss trading under the ITA, as well as the policy underlying the introduction of the SIFT conversion rules.

The court further ordered that the following types of documents be produced in un-redacted form:

  • GAAR committee meeting notes and minutes;

  • Memoranda to file written by CRA auditors;

  • Emails between CRA officials and auditors regarding the GAAR and loss trading; and

  • Memoranda to the GAAR committee from the Aggressive Tax Planning division of the CRA.

In summary, the Superior Plus Corp. decision appears to permit taxpayers to access GAAR committee communications, meeting minutes, and memoranda. The decision may help to encourage CRA transparency in the discovery process, particularly in matters concerning the GAAR or perhaps even when taxpayers seek such information through Freedom of Information processes.

Ed Kroft, QC (ed.kroft@blakes.com) and Casey Richardson-Scott (casey.richardsonscott@blakes.com), Toronto

Blake, Cassels & Graydon

Tel: +1 416 863 2500/+1 604 631 5200 and 1 416 863 4024

Website: www.blakes.com

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Heads of tax need to push their teams forward as strategic business advisers to add value across the organisation, says Sandy Markwick
Scott Bessent reportedly felt undermined by Musk naming Gary Shapley as acting IRS commissioner; in other news, Baker Tilly will combine with a top 15 US firm
The promise of nine years’ tax certainty and a ‘rational and pragmatic’ government process makes APAs a no-brainer, Indian tax advisers tell ITR
Despite garnering significant revenues from multinationals, Italy’s digital services tax presents pressing double taxation issues, say Stefano Simontacchi and Francesco Saverio Scandone of BonelliErede
ITR’s research shows that in-house tax counsel in Asia also feel underserved by their advisers’ international networks
World Tax global head of research Jon Moore tells ITR how his team spots standout submissions, and gives early statistical insights into this year’s entries
Australia’s conservative opposition will repeal controversial tax agent reporting rules if elected in the country’s May general election
Shapley would be the fourth person to hold the job this year; in other news, UK tax advisory firm MHA raised fewer funds than expected from its London IPO
The US needs to be involved in pillar one for there to be more international acceptance of the project, Michael Masciangelo says
The UK regulator is investigating EY’s auditing of the national postal service as it relates to the high-profile Horizon scandal, which saw hundreds wrongfully convicted
Gift this article