Germany: German Federal Tax Court rules disallowance of write-down for related-party debt violates OECD model treaty

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2025

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Germany: German Federal Tax Court rules disallowance of write-down for related-party debt violates OECD model treaty

Linn-Alexander-100
Braun-Thorsten-100

Alexander Linn

Thorsten Braun

The German Federal Tax Court (Bundesfinanzhof, BFH) issued a decision (case ref. I R 29/14) on September 9 2015, in which it held that the domestic transfer pricing rules may not be applied to disallow a write-down of an impaired related-party debt in a case where a relevant tax treaty includes the arm's-length standard provisions of Article 9 of the OECD model treaty.

Until 2007, German multinationals could claim a deduction for bad debts on loans granted to subsidiaries if the subsidiary did not perform as planned and the debt was impaired. As from 2008, write-downs of related-party loans are non-deductible under specific rules in the German Corporate Tax Act, unless it can be demonstrated that the loan was granted in line with (a very narrow interpretation of) the arm's-length principle.

In an effort to extend the general presumption of non-deductibility to the years before 2008, the German tax authorities challenged a 2002 write-down of a substantial unsecured debt owed by an undercapitalised UK subsidiary of a German entity of a Canadian group. The tax authorities argued that the German transfer pricing rules disallowed the write-down because either the loan was not granted on arm's-length terms, or the loan was not impaired because the subsidiary still could rely on the financial backing from its group, as long as it paid its third-party lenders.

The BFH confirmed a previous decision (case ref. I R 23/13) and emphasised that it may be in line with the arm's-length principle not to require collateral from a group subsidiary when granting a loan, and that it still may be possible to consider such a debt to be impaired if the subsidiary experiences financial difficulties. The BFH also confirmed that, where a tax treaty includes Article 9, paragraph 1 of the OECD model (as is the case with most German tax treaties), the domestic transfer pricing provisions may not disallow the write-down, since Article 9 permits only income adjustments relating to the conditions of the loan (for example, the interest rate); it does not permit the disallowance of a write-down. It is unclear if the same reasoning may be applied to years from 2008, where the deduction for a write-down is generally disallowed for reasons unrelated to the transfer pricing framework.

Alexander Linn (allinn@deloitte.de) and Thorsten Braun (tbraun@deloitte.de)

Deloitte

Tel: +49 89 29036 8558 and +49 69 75695 6444

Website: www.deloitte.de

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Heads of tax need to push their teams forward as strategic business advisers to add value across the organisation, says Sandy Markwick
Scott Bessent reportedly felt undermined by Musk naming Gary Shapley as acting IRS commissioner; in other news, Baker Tilly will combine with a top 15 US firm
The promise of nine years’ tax certainty and a ‘rational and pragmatic’ government process makes APAs a no-brainer, Indian tax advisers tell ITR
Despite garnering significant revenues from multinationals, Italy’s digital services tax presents pressing double taxation issues, say Stefano Simontacchi and Francesco Saverio Scandone of BonelliErede
ITR’s research shows that in-house tax counsel in Asia also feel underserved by their advisers’ international networks
World Tax global head of research Jon Moore tells ITR how his team spots standout submissions, and gives early statistical insights into this year’s entries
Australia’s conservative opposition will repeal controversial tax agent reporting rules if elected in the country’s May general election
Shapley would be the fourth person to hold the job this year; in other news, UK tax advisory firm MHA raised fewer funds than expected from its London IPO
The US needs to be involved in pillar one for there to be more international acceptance of the project, Michael Masciangelo says
The UK regulator is investigating EY’s auditing of the national postal service as it relates to the high-profile Horizon scandal, which saw hundreds wrongfully convicted
Gift this article